Fighting: Things my Japanese Husband and I Culturally Disagree About

Inner racial, innerracial Japanese American couple

Any relationship is hard. However, breaching two distinct cultures only adds another, complicated layer to the relationship schematics. While most of the guys I dated before I met Ryosuke came from a different country (three from Mexico, one from South Africa, one from France), I never really had any idea I was going to enter an interracial marriage.

But then I met Ryosuke. We knew each other a couple months before we started dating; less than a month after we made our relationship “Facebook Official,” he unofficially proposed and we started planning our lives together. Despite the fact we have been married for a while now, we’re still finding new things out about each other each month.

For a window into married life as the foreign wife of a Japanese husband, I recommend Wendy Tokunaga’s book, Marriage in Translation: Foreign Wife, Japanese Husband

But the more we learn about each other, the more we learn we are inherently and culturally different. My dad always told me to marry someone with a very high ability to “change” or adapt to a new environment; both Ryosuke and I have done a great deal of changing for each other. But we’ve also done a lot of learning.

[For more, check out: Asian Male, White Female Relationships: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly]

Look at that face! Does this look like the face of someone that would (purposefully) destroy an apartment?

I think one of the most rewarding aspects about being in a cross-cultural or interracial relationship is the fact that I am forced to examine my own culture (and values). Every time Ryosuke and I disagree about an aspect of our relationship, we are forced to confront why exactly we believe we are right (and I’m not allowed to say “Because I’m a woman, therefore I’m always right!”).

[For more, check out: I will never be (legally) his: Problems Facing Interracial Couples in Japan]

I wanted to make a mini-series about all the things Ryosuke and I seem to disagree with culturally. I wanted to do this partially for reflection, partially because I thought it might interest people who have no experience with Japanese culture, partially because I thought it might interest or align with what people with a great deal of Japanese cultural experience have noticed, and partially because I wanted to help future foreign women dating Japanese men. I wanted to give them a list of things to expect with their Japanese boyfriend.

Inner racial, innerracial Japanese American couple

The main thing my Japanese Husband and I have different ideas on is…

Fighting

I like to fight. Or, I don’t actually like to fight, per say, but I think constructive fighting and arguing has a very vital role in any healthy relationship. I believe both sides should be able to safely confront the other about behavior that bothers them, issues they’ve been holding in, or other concerns without bottling it up. In a perfect world, we would be able to sit down once a month or so and just talk about the things that were bothering us – and such a conversation would rarely lead to actual yelling. I can count on one hand the number of times we’ve actually yelled at each other during a “fight” in the last year and a half. We didn’t start out that way, though.

Inner racial, innerracial Japanese American couple

Needless to say, Ryosuke’s views on fighting and arguing are quite different. He was raised in a somewhat non-confrontational society. While he is one of the most confrontational Japanese people I know, sometimes he will shy away from conflict. Especially when said conflict seems to be rocking an otherwise stable boat (hint – the boat is our relationship). This also isn’t a uniquely Ryosuke aspect, most of my friend who have dated a Japanese man or have Japanese boyfriends have complained about this: Japanese men don’t like to fight.

If sometime bothers Ryosuke, he would prefer to keep it in. When he’s sad, mad, frustrated, or angry with me, he will kind of shut down, and I have to awkwardly sit across from him for the next half an hour or so, waiting for him to compose himself and gather his thoughts. All of my friends have complained about similar things. It seems like most Japanese boyfriends have inherent problems with effectively communicating their feelings. In my opinion, this isn’t good.

Inner racial, innerracial Japanese American couple

I knew an American girl who had been dating this Japanese man for two years. She was bragging to me how not once, in their two years together, had they ever gotten into even a simple argument. “We always agree on everything,” she bragged, “we’re not like those other couples who fight all the time!” I started to wonder if maybe she was right, was I pushing Ryosuke to fight too much? Would we be better off not confronting each other that often?

Three days later, she went to meet up with her boyfriend. She was very excited because they hadn’t seen each other in a month or so. She thought he was going to propose.

But he dumped her.

 

Add me on Google Plus: +Grace Buchele

Enter your email address to subscribe to Texan in Tokyo (you won't regret it!)

About Grace Buchele Mineta

Born and raised in Texas, I am a part-time blogger on the search for the next greatest adventure. In my spare time I enjoy writing, drawing comics, and traveling with my husband, a boxing businessman from Japan. Contact: Website | More Posts

39 Comments on Fighting: Things my Japanese Husband and I Culturally Disagree About

  1. Sorry to say this, but your husband really looks like monkey.

  2. I know this is an old post, but feel like I can pitch in, because it reminded me of our (my now-wife and myself) early courtship. She was sooo afraid that she might be doing something I didn’t like but I was not telling her (“Please, please tell me if I am doing something wrong!”). I was also taken back at first by how much SHE WANTED TO TALK, and got frustrated when I was not as responsive as she wanted. (Though, I must say, the whole ‘an communicative BF/husband frustrates GF/wife’ thing is a fairly common trope in the US, too, isn’t it? Looks like half of rom-coms/sitcoms are built around ‘monosyllabic men and their chatty GFs/wives’ setup.)
    Ah, fighting–I must say I don’t like arguing, either, and I don’t find it as constructive, as you and other (female) commenters here seem to believe, but it makes me uncomfortable to be placed on the ‘opposite sides,’ as if we are enemies. So I really do NOT recommend those women with Japanese BF/husband to push him to argue. He may just take it as a sign that you don’t love him as he is, or, at least, you don’t value the bond he and you have already built together (i.e., he may think you are trying to break up). My now-wife used to try to bait me into a fight, but after they led to several bad (i.e., not constructive at all!) outcomes, she, perhaps grudgingly ;-), has changed her tactic.
    Nowadays, when she doesn’t like certain things in our relationship, instead of a fight/argument, she brings it up as a topic for a sort of a brainstorming session–no ‘winner’ or ‘loser’ but we, being on the ‘same side,’ offer ideas to improve. Funny thing is, I think my wife likes that way, too! haha. If Ryo-kun is somewhat like me, instead of starting with what he does that makes you unhappy and demand a change (and expects him to push back in hope of a ‘constructive fight’), I would recommend you to ask him/solicit his suggestions re: what you TWO can do to make you TWO happiER than now. After all, that IS what you want in the end, right? An argument/fight in a couple can accidentally go where neither party wants to go (e.g., awakening your deep-seated insecurity, touching a past incident you’d rather not recall), so why take a risk? And that may be precisely why Ryo-kun is acting the way he does. Give him some credit! :-)

  3. You guys look really cute!

  4. I’ve never understood the need people have/feel to fight to communicate and clear things up. This year will make 20 years I’ve been with my wife. (Though not married anywhere near that long, heh) We have never had a fight, less than a dozen times that I can think of that we strongly disagreed on something that took more than a day to resolve, but still no fighting, no yelling, no going to bed angry and none of the crazy drama that I see so many going through. We discussed this when we first started dating too. I don’t like to fight and its not necessary for good communication, sex isn’t a tool and shouldn’t be used as a treat or a punishment, things like that. My aunt and uncle are on the other end of the spectrum; they *thrive* on fighting! If I took someone new to see them you would think someone would be killing someone soon! After a while as family we learn to tune it out and consider it entertainment! (Kid you not!). I don’t get how they both don’t have ulcers, I know I would! …and it’s not like I’m a quiet, shy reserved person either… (Hah!)
    Mike in Texas

  5. I’m married to a Chinese man and I know how you feel. I’ve definitely learned the meaning of “pick and choose your battles”, and if it’s a small issue, I just give my husband space and by the evening or the next day, things are back to normal. If it’s an issue that’s reoccurring, then I’ll talk to him about it. Even then, sometimes it helps to have a couple of days of space (not ignoring each other, but not directly facing the issue yet) until you’ve both calmed down and then bring it up again.

    • I agree. I’ve gotten a lot better at picking my battles – which is difficult, because I have to consciously decide to let something go.

      A couple of weeks ago, when my husband and I were in Texas visiting my parents, he was shocked by the amount of arguing between my parents and other siblings (and between my siblings and I). I tried explaining to him that this was just the way we were raised, but he was still a bit off-put by the constant discussion. I don’t blame him, it can be tiring, but it was a nice window into cultural differences.

      Thank you for sharing. I knew avoiding direct confrontation was a somewhat Japanese trait, but I didn’t realize it could also encompass Chinese men. Interesting.

  6. Ah I’m married to a half japanese, half guamanian (chamorro) guy, he TOTALLY would do the whole quiet, avoid it, sleep on it thing too! I guess it is totally cultural. He’s opened up a lot more now though :D And I’ve learned to listen… -_-

    • I’ve gotten a lot better at listening too (no fun). I guess it really is a cultural thing.

      • I think especially since I’m half german and half mexican (but born in the US), I was so used to passionate arguing and I thought thats what you did if you wanted to make it work. I was so confused when he wouldn’t say anything! But now we’ve been married almost 3 years (been friends for like 9) and we have a total multi-racial baby! Anywho, finding your blog is so refreshing as a “white girl” with a japanese guy!

        • Oh that must have been fun. I love reading about intercultural relationships :)
          Congrats on the happy marriage and child!

          PS – if you have any other blog recommendations, I would love to read them!

    • I am dating a korean man and it is the same for them as well. They do not handle conflict
      well bc they just try to avoid it all together. I enjoy healthy discussion about differences. we have both grown a lot because of it.

      • I’m glad to hear you have been able to grow through healthy discussion. More and more, I’m starting to think this aversion to fighting is a sort of “Asian” concept.

  7. When discussing stuff, it helps to remember that conversation in America is like playing tennis; lots of back and forth. In Japan, conversation is like bowling; only one person is speaking at a time and all others are listening. However when it’s your turn you can pretty much speak about whatever you want and the listeners will back channel verbal noises that say they’re politely engaged (but the noises should NOT be confused with agreement. They’re just saying “Uh huh, i am still listening.”). Interruption is considered rude unless you’re the higher status individual.
    Also it helps to pay attention to the wide range of verbal noises. They can mean everything from, “That’s NEVER gonna happen…” to “Shut Up! You gotta be kidding me!”

    • That’s probably the best analogy I’ve seen for the differences between Japanese/American conversations. I’m going to share this with my fiance when he gets home from work.

      I used to make the mistake of interrupting friends when I was talking to them – but after a couple months I learned it is best to just kind of spout out the verbal “un” “soka” “hmmm” etc. It’s interesting.
      But thanks for the explanation!

  8. Your posts are always very interesting to read, thank you, because of course you need time to write.
    I would love to ask you about a topic and I am sure more people would agree with me.
    What about writing a guide on “how to date japanese guy ?”
    And I am talking about trying to estabilish a serious relationiship, not that interracial relationiship that last a couple of months (or more).
    Once I was invited from a japanese guy (almost man) but to be honest I refused because I didn’t know how to behave. If we go dinner/drink I have to pay for myself ? Does he choose where to go ? If he asks me about, can I choose or is he asking just to be polite ? If we are late and metro is closed and HE call a taxi, do I have to pay or will he pay the driver before ?
    And if we take the taxi togheter and he left me home first, then he, do i have to give him my part of fare ?
    I am sure there are much more question I -and the others, too- need to ask, but i can’t remember now.

    Grace-sama please, help us !

    • Hahahaha, oh my gosh, that sounds like a GREAT idea!
      I will ask my fiance to help me out (I’m saving your questions in a Word document) and will write it in the next couple days! Thanks for the idea~

      (dating inter-racially, especially with Japan, is so hard…)

  9. I’ve always thought my boyfriend is a complete push over, but reading this I am wondering whether it is a cultural thing more than a personality thing. (Assuming this stretches to Asian and not just Japan). If I give him options to do anything, he’ll always say he’ll do whatever I want to do, and if we have an argument he gives in almost instantly. Strangely, it winds me up even more when we are having a disagreement if he won’t argue back! At times, I also feel like I have to be careful that I’m not taking advantage of him when he acts this way.

    • I completely agree. I think it is a sort of “Asian value” among men. It took nearly a year of dating before I was able to convince my boyfriend fighting (in small doses and when done correctly) is actually a GOOD thing in a relationship.

      I still estimate that I win our arguments about 90% of the time, which really isn’t a good sign at all. It’s so hard to not take advantage or pull pot shots on someone who won’t argue back. I agree, it also winds me up pretty hard.

  10. Ouch!! He dumped her…..sometimes we can mistake passive aggressive behavior for compliance, and get too self-absorb and not realize the other person is unhappy.

    Or maybe she was already self-absorb person.

    So it’s not about “fighting” but truly asking your partner, are you happy, and if not how can we fix it?

    • gracebuchele // 7 August, 2013 at 1:27 pm // Reply

      I would go out on a limb and say she was one of the most self-absorbed people I’ve ever met. Even so, breakups are always hard.

      I think I agree. It is more about communication than actually arguing – just because the other person doesn’t actively say “I’m not happy” doesn’t mean they are, in fact, happy in the relationship. It’s hard, right?

  11. Nice to read your take on dating a Japanese guy. It’s really frustrating searching for other North American women who are dating Japanese guys. Especially with the fighting thing, I think it’s really important to fight. Not a spiteful fight, but just to get things out and learn. But, my boyfriend hates it, too.
    Shameless plug because I just wrote about something similar tonight, and found your site searching about this topic! Good luck!
    http://the-maruhi-club.blogspot.jp/2013/07/dating-in-japan-as-american-woman.html

    • gracebuchele // 29 July, 2013 at 8:30 pm // Reply

      I loved your post. It rings very true on so many levels.

      I’ve actually met several older women married to Japanese men – but never met someone my own age dating a Japanese man (who, you know, stayed in the relationships…)
      I think fighting/communication is the most important thing (kind of like what you said on your post). It’s hard. Do y’all live in America/have you talked about marriage? Or is it kind of left at the “impossible” level?

      • I’m living in Japan. But, since my bf is a programmer I’m trying to get him interested in moving to the US. It’d be a great career move for him. But, he lived in the US as a kid, and he’s kind of wishy-washy about moving. He’s talked about marriage, but I tell him not to rush things haha!
        I can literally count on one hand the number of non-Japanese women I know married to Japanese guys and living in Japan. The non-Japanese guys married to Japanese women on the other hand… :P

        • gracebuchele // 8 August, 2013 at 8:41 am // Reply

          I know, right? It’s a big difference. Good luck with the move! (and I have noticed there are several Japanese men rushing into marriage. Or just everyone is rushing into marriage. It’s hard to tell).

  12. That was a really interesting article. As a Chinese girl dating a White boy, I’m very excited to read more of your miniseries on interracial couples and the cultural differences that affect the relationship.

  13. Totally makes sense from past interactions I’ve had with Japanese people.

    And may I say your fiance is pretty hot! :)

  14. I oddly loved how you ended this. “He dumped her.”

    • I found the story kind of sad…
      I don’t know the “right” way to do a Japanese man/American woman relationship. But I’ve learned one way that hasn’t worked out…
      And this is basically how it goes with relationships. You think you know something, and then suddenly it doesn’t work.

  15. you two look absolutely adorable and i love the way you wrote this. i am also in an “inter-racial” relationship – i am chinese and my 2.5yr boyfriend is australian. i must agree that constructive fighting (similar to criticism) is healthy for a relationship to prosper and develop. i can’t wait to hear more regarding this topic!

    • I wish you all the best in your relationship. 2.5 years in a Loooooong time!
      Do you have any advice about interracial relationships?

      I’m planning on doing a mini-series on this, with a couple of the other topics we disagree on (cleanliness, relationship with parents, racism, cheating, etc).

      • i don’t really have any great advice on interracial relationships as this guy is my first and only boyfriend. i just believe that the key to any relationship is honesty which can be achieved by talking to each other – whether it be about something mundane, superficial or huge as. i think your partner should be your best friend and he/she should be the first people you want to tell something to.

        as for topics, i totally agree with the cleanliness topic as well as marriage is not only with your fiance but also with their parents and family members (depending on which one is asian). i also think that it might be good to do one on divorce and the cultural differences with regards to divorce (and cheating). oh and another topic could be about having children and the difference in the asian upbringing vs caucasian upbringing. i don’t know if this is what you are looking for but i hope it has helped! :)

        • Now that you mention it, the divorce thing sounds really interesting (you know, considering the high divorce rates in America vs Japan). I’m trying to do a “relationship related” post every Wednesday, I think that’s going to be my next one. Thanks!

          Actually, Ryosuke’s kind of my first boyfriend too. I mean I dated before, but I hadn’t had a relationship last longer than a month (that was my breaking point, if I didn’t love them after a month, they had to go. It was kind of heartless). I do agree with you on the honesty and communication area, though.

7 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Grace & Ryosuke – Akita, Japan | Chonilla.com
  2. Would you ever date a foreigner? Would you marry her? Thoughts from Japanese men | Texan in Tokyo
  3. AMWF Relationships: The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly (Asian Male, White Female Couples) | Texan in Tokyo
  4. Things I don’t Understand about Japan: The Japanese Break-up Method | Texan in Tokyo
  5. Texan-Japanese Intercultural Marriage – Finding Your Best Friend Beyond Race
  6. “Just because you CAN eat a lot, doesn’t mean you SHOULD…” And other Japanese thoughts on American Overindulgence | Texan in Tokyo
  7. Guest Post: 7 of the Best Things about being married to a Non-Native English Speaker | Speaking of China

Share your thoughts:

%d bloggers like this: